The Way of the Intellectual Dark Web: What Joe Rogan and His Associates Can Teach Us about Political Dialogue

The Intellectual Dark Web (IDW) is a cultural and intellectual phenomenon that has gained a vast global audience since the mid-2010s, encompassing a range of public intellectuals such as Joe Rogan, Jordan Peterson, Eric and Bret Weinstein, Ben Shapiro, Heather Heying, and Sam Harris. Roberts provides a rigorous and accessible assessment of the movement's origins, philosophy, cultural importance, and limitations, asking how far it has lived up to its goal of moving beyond polarisation and radicalisation.

Format: Paperback / softback
Length: 206 pages
Publication date: 31 January 2024
Publisher: Taylor & Francis Ltd

The Intellectual Dark Web (IDW) has emerged as a groundbreaking cultural and intellectual phenomenon since the mid-2010s. Through podcasts and YouTube videos, a new generation of public intellectuals has gained a vast global audience, including notable figures such as Joe Rogan, Jordan Peterson, Eric and Bret Weinstein, Ben Shapiro, Heather Heying, and Sam Harris. This movement has encompassed a diverse range of individuals, often associated with different fields and perspectives. Steven Pinker, Jonathan Haidt, Elon Musk, Niall Ferguson, and Stephen Fry are among those who have been linked to the IDW. The movement is characterized by a sprawling and ever-growing list of participants who have appeared on IDW podcasts and videos, started their own podcasts, and share a common ethos. While it is dispersed, the IDW's influence is significant, with millions of people globally accessing these online outlets.

In his book, "The Intellectual Dark Web: Origins, Shared Philosophy, Cultural Importance, and Limitations," author Roberts provides a rigorous and accessible assessment of the IDW's origins, shared philosophy, cultural significance, and limitations. Roberts delves into the historical context of the movement, exploring its roots in the internet age and the rise of alternative media platforms. He examines the core ideas espoused by the IDW members and critically assesses their coherence, impact on politics and public discourse, and the extent to which they have lived up to their professed goal of moving beyond polarisation and radicalisation.

One of the key themes explored in the book is the IDW's emphasis on free speech and intellectual honesty. The movement advocates for a more open and inclusive society where individuals are allowed to express their ideas without fear of censorship or suppression. Roberts argues that the IDW's commitment to free speech is essential for promoting intellectual growth and fostering constructive dialogue. However, he also acknowledges the challenges associated with this approach, such as the need to balance free speech with the need to prevent hate speech and misinformation.

Another important aspect of the IDW is its focus on critical thinking and rationality. The movement encourages its members to approach issues with a scientific mindset and to rely on evidence-based reasoning. Roberts highlights the importance of this approach in navigating the complex and often polarised world of contemporary politics. He also criticises the tendency of some IDW members to dismiss or ignore scientific evidence when it contradicts their beliefs, emphasizing the need for a more rigorous and evidence-based approach to problem-solving.

The IDW's cultural significance is another topic explored in the book. Roberts argues that the movement has played a significant role in challenging mainstream media narratives and promoting alternative perspectives. He notes that the IDW has provided a platform for individuals who have been marginalised or silenced by the mainstream media, allowing them to express their ideas and reach a wider audience. However, Roberts also raises concerns about the potential impact of the IDW on public discourse, particularly in terms of its influence on young people and the spread of misinformation.

In conclusion, "The Intellectual Dark Web: Origins, Shared Philosophy, Cultural Importance, and Limitations" is an insightful read for both followers of the IDW looking for a coherent and critical overview and for students of popular culture looking to understand this massive but decentralised popular intellectual movement. Roberts provides a comprehensive analysis of the IDW's origins, shared philosophy, cultural significance, and limitations, offering valuable insights into this evolving phenomenon. Through his rigorous and accessible approach, Roberts encourages readers to engage with the ideas presented and to consider the broader implications of the IDW on society and politics.

Weight: 338g
Dimension: 156 x 234 x 25 (mm)
ISBN-13: 9781032330693