Can We Know Anything?: A Debate

Michael Huemer and Bryan Frances debate whether we can gain knowledge of the world outside of our own minds, with Huemer arguing that we are entitled to presume that things are as they appear unless and until we acquire specific grounds for thinking otherwise. Frances argues that we should generally withhold judgment about controversial issues or at least greatly reduce our confidence.

Format: Paperback / softback
Length: 210 pages
Publication date: 19 September 2023
Publisher: Taylor & Francis Ltd

In this captivating book, Michael Huemer and Bryan Frances engage in a lively and thought-provoking debate about the nature and scope of our knowledge of the world outside our own minds. The debate unfolds through two rounds ofReplies, where Frances argues that our lack of knowledge stems from our inability to rule out the possibility that we are merely brains in vats, being artificially stimulated to create an illusion of living in the real world. Huemer, on the other hand, contends that we do not necessarily need evidence against such possibilities to gain knowledge of the external world. Instead, he maintains that we are entitled to presume that things are as they appear unless and until we acquire specific grounds for thinking otherwise.

The authors then delve into the complexities of controversial issues where experts persistently disagree. Frances suggests that we should generally withhold judgment or at least significantly reduce our confidence in such matters. Huemer, while agreeing that people often exhibit overconfidence in controversial issues, attempts to carve out exceptions where rational belief in controversial views is possible.

This book offers a comprehensive exploration of the topic, making it accessible to readers at all levels. It presents the arguments from two leading philosophers in standard form and in clear language, ensuring that the ideas are easily understandable. Definitions are provided in an easily accessible manner, and summary boxes recap key arguments. An annotated bibliography and glossary of all specialized vocabulary further enhance the reader's understanding of the subject matter.

In conclusion, "The Knowledge Argument: Why You Don't Know What You Think You Know" is a must-read for anyone interested in philosophy, epistemology, and the nature of knowledge. It provides a thought-provoking and engaging debate between two esteemed philosophers, offering insights and perspectives that will challenge and expand your understanding of the world.

Weight: 280g
Dimension: 138 x 217 x 15 (mm)
ISBN-13: 9780367208875