Critical Views of Logic

This book explores positions that challenge the Fregean logic-first view, suggesting that we should not be dogmatic about logic but ask critical questions about it, similar to those Kant raised about metaphysics and mathematics. It explores views that assign primacy to mathematical reasons, Kantian metaphysical grounds, Husserlian transcendental phenomenological reflection, or normative considerations about how terms ought to be defined in various fields of empirical science or mathematics.

Format: Unspecified
Length: 220 pages
Publication date: 31 October 2023
Publisher: Taylor & Francis Ltd

This book delves into positions that challenge the Fregean logic-first view, raising critical questions about logic by examining the intricate connections between logic, mathematics, and metaphysics. It prompts us to reconsider our assumptions about logic and to adopt a more nuanced perspective. Is logic truly topic-neutral and universal, or can we take its application for granted? This book suggests that we should not be dogmatic about logic but rather raise similar critical inquiries about it as Kant did regarding metaphysics and mathematics. It challenges the Fregean logic-first view, which posits logic as fundamental and independent of any extra-logical considerations.

While Quine integrated logic and mathematics into the theoretical aspects of empirical science, this volume explores views that stop short of his thoroughgoing holism but instead take logic to be answerable to or entangled with specific disciplines. The contributions present diverse viewpoints that prioritize mathematical reasons, Kantian metaphysical grounds, Husserlian transcendental phenomenological reflection, or normative considerations about how terms should be defined in various fields of empirical science or mathematics. This creates a space between a Fregean position and Quinean holism.

Critical Views of Logic will be an invaluable resource for academics, researchers, and advanced students in philosophy, linguistics, mathematics, computer science, as well as those engaged in various empirical science fields. The chapters in this book, except for chapter 4, were originally published in the journal Inquiry.

Weight: 585g
Dimension: 234 x 156 (mm)
ISBN-13: 9781032573519