Deliberative Theory and Deconstruction: A Democratic Venture

In a political climate increasingly characterised by hostility towards constructed others, Steven Gormley develops a critical dialogue between deliberative theory and deconstruction to explore what it means to do justice to the other and how we can respond to this demand. He argues that doing justice to the other requires a democratic form of politics and a commitment to an ethos of interruption.

Format: Paperback / softback
Length: 320 pages
Publication date: 31 May 2022
Publisher: Edinburgh University Press

In a political landscape marked by growing hostility towards constructed others, Steven Gormley delves into the profound question of what it means to do justice to the other and how we can respond to this urgent demand. Through a rigorous yet constructive dialogue between deliberative theory and deconstruction, he seeks to unravel the complexities of this issue. Two central claims emerge from this insightful exploration: firstly, that doing justice to the other necessitates a steadfast commitment to interruption; and secondly, that such an ethos demands a democratic form of politics.

To develop this comprehensive account, Gormley brings deliberative theory and deconstruction into critical conversation with the diverse works of Mouffe, Aristotle, Rorty, Laclau, and various traditions of critical theory. By engaging in this dialogue, he sheds light on the ways in which these different perspectives contribute to our understanding of justice and the role of politics in achieving it.

Deliberative theory, as Gormley explains, emphasizes the importance of rational deliberation and collective decision-making as means of promoting justice and resolving conflicts. It posits that individuals can come together to engage in meaningful dialogue, exchange ideas, and reach mutually beneficial agreements. Through this process, they can cultivate a sense of shared responsibility and mutual respect, which are essential for building inclusive and just societies.

On the other hand, deconstruction challenges the notion of fixed and universal truths and exposes the underlying power structures and ideologies that shape our understanding of the other. It questions the very foundations of our moral and ethical frameworks, challenging us to think critically about the ways in which we construct and categorize others. Deconstruction encourages us to recognize the inherent biases and prejudices that exist within our societies and to work towards dismantling them.

By integrating deliberative theory and deconstruction, Gormley offers a nuanced and comprehensive account of what it means to do justice to the other. He highlights the importance of interruption as a means of challenging dominant narratives and promoting alternative perspectives. He also emphasizes the need for democratic politics, which provides a platform for marginalized voices and ensures that the interests of all members of society are taken into account.

In conclusion, Steven Gormley's work is a valuable contribution to the ongoing debate about justice and the role of politics in achieving it. Through his rigorous dialogue between deliberative theory and deconstruction, he provides a rich and nuanced understanding of the challenges and opportunities that arise in our efforts to do justice to the other. By engaging with the diverse perspectives of other thinkers and traditions, he offers a roadmap for building more inclusive and just societies.

Dimension: 216 x 138 (mm)
ISBN-13: 9781474475297