Epistemic Paternalism: Conceptions, Justifications and Implications

This volume explores the moral and epistemic implications of information manipulation and restriction in contemporary society, including medical practice, science communication, and research. It discusses whether unconsenting interference with people's ability to inquire is consistent with efforts to democratize knowledge and decision-making.

Format: Paperback / softback
Length: 332 pages
Publication date: 15 May 2022
Publisher: Rowman & Littlefield

This comprehensive volume delves into the intricate realms of information manipulation and restriction in contemporary society, posing profound questions about the ethical and epistemic implications of such practices. It explores the possibility of manipulating the conditions of inquiry without the consent of those affected, raising crucial ethical dilemmas. The contributors offer a wealth of examples and engage in spirited debates regarding the distinction between epistemic paternalism and other forms of paternalism debated in political theory.

Special attention is given to various domains, including medical practice, science communication, and research in science, technology, and society. Some contributors argue that unconsenting interference with individuals' ability to inquire is compatible with efforts to democratize knowledge and decision-making, while others contend that it contradicts these goals. These differing perspectives prompt deep theoretical reflection on the fundamental values at stake, the boundaries between informing and instructing, and the potential implications of manipulating people's epistemic conditions.

The collection also highlights contemporary paternalistic practices in the realm of big data and scientific research, where the manipulations of a small group of experts or algorithms can curtail the flow of information or knowledge. This raises important concerns about the power dynamics and the potential for intellectual injustice in these contexts.

Overall, this volume provides a valuable exploration of the complex dynamics of information manipulation and restriction, shedding light on the ethical, epistemic, and societal implications of these practices. It serves as a crucial resource for scholars, policymakers, and individuals interested in understanding the challenges and opportunities posed by the evolving information landscape.

Weight: 503g
Dimension: 219 x 155 x 24 (mm)
ISBN-13: 9781538171233