Genderless Grammar: How to Promote Inclusivity without Destroying Languages

Attempts to conceal grammatical gender, dictated by the inclusive desire to overcome gender binarism and make room for the neutral, are affecting the national languages of Western countries with increasing frequency and intensity, risking weakening or compromising the functioning of the languages supporting structures. This ends up making even the simple decoding of information difficult.

Format: Paperback / softback
Length: 110 pages
Publication date: 23 March 2023
Publisher: Peter Lang AG, Internationaler Verlag der Wissenschaften

The growing trend of attempts to conceal grammatical gender, driven by the inclusive desire to transcend the binary distinction between masculine and feminine (gender binarism) and create space for the neutral, is increasingly impacting the national languages of various Western countries. This phenomenon is manifesting with increasing frequency and intensity, posing a significant risk to the robustness and integrity of the languages that support essential structures. It is crucial to recognize that a grammatical innovation holds a distinct impact compared to a neologism. When such an innovation, purportedly driven by inclusivity, infiltrates public acts or any other textual content issued or produced by public entities, it permeates the text in a pervasive manner. This raises concerns, particularly when it comes to institutional endorsement, as it should trigger alarm bells.

In our specific context, the oversimplification of overlapping two levels that should be maintained as distinct—one structural (technical-linguistic) and the other superstructural (socio-cultural)—leads to a situation where the structures of an idiom, particularly when stratified over time, are manipulated to accommodate the desires of individuals who, defying logic and common sense, demand immediate changes that could disrupt or undermine the linguistic system. This outcome not only makes the simple decoding of information challenging but also undermines the stability and coherence of the language.

To address this issue, it is essential to promote a nuanced approach that recognizes the inherent complexities of grammatical gender and the cultural and societal factors that shape its expression. This requires a deeper understanding of the linguistic and cultural heritage of each language community, as well as a commitment to preserving and promoting its unique linguistic characteristics. It is also crucial to encourage dialogue and collaboration among linguists, policymakers, and community members to find sustainable solutions that balance inclusivity and linguistic integrity. By adopting a balanced and respectful approach, we can ensure that the national languages of Western countries continue to thrive and evolve while preserving their rich linguistic heritage for future generations.

Weight: 160g
Dimension: 147 x 210 x 9 (mm)
ISBN-13: 9782875747426
Edition number: New ed