Holding Wrongdoers Responsible: On the Complexities of Blame and Forgiveness

Holding Wrongdoers Responsible challenges common beliefs about blame and forgiveness, suggesting that anger is not the only appropriate response to wrongdoing, that blame is not always necessary, and that forgiving can be complex and challenging.

Format: Paperback / softback
Length: 254 pages
Publication date: 31 May 2023
Publisher: Taylor & Francis Ltd

Holding Wrongdoers Responsible challenges several widely accepted claims about blame and forgiveness that require further examination in the philosophical literature. These claims include:
1. Anger is the most appropriate form of blame for those who engage in wrongdoing.
2. Culpable wrongdoers deserve to be held accountable for their actions.
3. Forgiveness involves renouncing blame and negative emotions, particularly anger.
4. Forgiveness is a compassionate act that wrongdoers should appreciate.

Against (i), the book argues that there are several reasons to be skeptical about the exclusive emphasis placed on anger in this context. It challenges the notion that anger is the sole or most fitting response to wrongdoing and suggests that blame should be evaluated in terms of its intended purposes and the available alternatives. Against (ii), the book contends that blame is just one possible response to wrongdoing and should be considered alongside other responses, such as rehabilitation, restitution, or reconciliation. It emphasizes the need to evaluate the effectiveness and ethical implications of different responses to wrongdoing. Against (iii), the book challenges the notion that the continuation of blame after forgiveness is inherently problematic or morally wrong. It suggests that blame can be a valuable tool for accountability, learning, and growth, particularly in cases where ongoing harm or risk is present. Against (iv), the book challenges the portrayal of forgiveness as a benevolent and gift-like act, suggesting that it can conceal its darker side. It explores the potential negative effects of forgiveness, such as the reinforcement of power imbalances, the suppression of emotions, and the potential for further harm. By contesting these claims, the book aims to reveal the moral and psychological complexities associated with blame, forgiveness, and their relationship to each other.

Weight: 490g
Dimension: 229 x 152 (mm)
ISBN-13: 9781032139470