How Sherlock Pulled the Trick: Spiritualism and the Pseudoscientific Method

How Sherlock Pulled the Trick explores the connection between Sherlock Holmes and his creator, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, arguing that Holmes follows the same circular logic and questionable evidence that led Doyle to spiritualism. This book challenges the idea that wearing a deerstalker makes one a mastermind and reveals that Holmes's logical reasoning has evolved into pseudoscience that corrupts our public sphere.

Format: Hardback
Length: 208 pages
Publication date: 01 June 2021
Publisher: Pennsylvania State University Press

A captivating blend of literary analysis and author biography, How Sherlock Pulled the Trick delves into the intertwined careers of two inseparable figures: Sherlock Holmes and his creator, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. By reevaluating Holmes in the context of Doyle's renowned belief in Victorian spiritualism, Brian McCuskey compellingly argues that the so-called scientific detective employs the same circular logic and follows a similar trail of questionable evidence that led Doyle to the realm of séances. The genesis of Holmes's remarkable journey can be traced back to the publication of his first case, "A Study in Scarlet," in 1887. At that time, the scientific community and religious apologists were engaged in heated debates in the London press, fervently contesting their differing perspectives. In this dynamic environment, Doyle developed a profound conviction that spiritualism, as a universal faith grounded in tangible evidence, possessed the power to bridge the gap between science and religion. Consequently, the character of Holmes emerged as Doyle's sincere and thoughtful response to the cultural conflicts of his era. However, it is important to note that this solution, initially intended to foster harmony, has inadvertently evolved into a new challenge. As this book vividly illustrates, donning a deerstalker does not automatically confer upon one the status of a mastermind. Rather, it often serves as a conspicuous marker of eccentricity, marking an individual as a questionable figure.

How Sherlock Pulled the Trick is a fascinating and immensely readable work that reclaims the enigmatic Holmes for his mystical origins. Through meticulous research and insightful analysis, McCuskey unveils the intricate connections between the life and writings of Conan Doyle and the iconic character of Sherlock Holmes. By delving into the spiritual influences that shaped Doyle's worldview, the book sheds light on the profound impact that these beliefs had on the creation of Holmes. It explores how Doyle's belief in spiritualism influenced the detective's methods, his approach to solving cases, and even his underlying moral compass. The book also examines the ways in which Holmes's popularity has contributed to the perpetuation of pseudoscience, misinformation, and conspiracy theories. It raises important questions about the role of literature and popular culture in shaping public perception and the responsibility of authors to navigate the complexities of their creations.

In conclusion, How Sherlock Pulled the Trick is a groundbreaking exploration of the enigmatic relationship between Sherlock Holmes and his creator, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. Through meticulous scholarship and compelling storytelling, Brian McCuskey offers a fresh perspective on the iconic detective, challenging our assumptions and illuminating the profound impact of literature, spirituality, and cultural influences on the shaping of one of the greatest fictional characters in history. This book is a must-read for fans of Sherlock Holmes, literature, and the mysteries of the human mind.

Weight: 466g
Dimension: 162 x 235 x 25 (mm)
ISBN-13: 9780271089874