Is Ireland Neutral: The Many Myths of Irish Neutrality

Neutrality is a vague, flimsy, and elastic notion that governments have been happy to stretch or abandon. In the face of aggression, is it right to sit back and do nothing? And is it even possible to be neutral in an interconnected world?

Format: Paperback / softback
Length: 336 pages
Publication date: 01 June 2023
Publisher: Gill

Neutrality, a cornerstone of Ireland's national identity, has long been celebrated as a steadfast principle that has weathered the test of time. However, upon closer inspection, the concept reveals itself to be a vague, flimsy, and elastic notion that has been subject to manipulation and disregard by various governments throughout history. In the modern era, warfare has undergone a remarkable transformation, expanding to encompass a wide range of challenges, including cyberattacks, environmental concerns, election interference, and disinformation. As the nature of conflict evolves, it becomes increasingly pertinent to question whether our traditional understanding of neutrality should likewise adapt.

In his insightful book, "Choosing a Side: The Ethics of Neutrality in a Complex World," Conor Gallagher delves into these pressing questions. Gallagher challenges the notion that neutrality is inherently virtuous and argues that it can, in fact, be a dangerous and ineffective approach to conflict resolution. He highlights the historical instances where neutrality has been abandoned or manipulated, such as during World War II when Ireland remained neutral despite the overwhelming evidence of **** atrocities. Gallagher also examines the practical implications of neutrality, particularly in the context of contemporary international relations. He questions whether a country can truly remain neutral in the face of aggression, given the interconnectedness of the global economy and the potential for economic sanctions and other forms of retaliation.

Furthermore, Gallagher explores the ethical dimensions of neutrality. He questions whether it is morally acceptable to sit back and do nothing while innocent people suffer at the hands of aggressors. He also raises concerns about the role of neutrality in perpetuating inequality and injustice, as it can allow powerful countries to exploit weaker ones without facing consequences.

In conclusion, Conor Gallagher's "Choosing a Side: The Ethics of Neutrality in a Complex World" is a must-read for anyone interested in understanding the complexities of neutrality and its implications for global politics. Through his thoughtful analysis and compelling arguments, Gallagher challenges the reader to reevaluate the concept of neutrality and consider alternative approaches to conflict resolution that prioritize justice, peace, and human rights.

Weight: 444g
Dimension: 154 x 234 x 26 (mm)
ISBN-13: 9780717195992