Magic's Reason: An Anthropology of Analogy

In Magic's Reason, Graham M. Jones explores the relationship between anthropology and entertainment magic, showing how they shared attitudes towards modernity and rationality. He argues that anthropologists should not dismiss the concept of magic but should critically assess its colonial origins, developing a new perspective on cross-cultural comparisons.

\n Format: Paperback / softback
\n Length: 240 pages
\n Publication date: 06 December 2017
\n Publisher: The University of Chicago Press
\n

In his captivating book, "Magic's Reason," Graham M. Jones delves into the intricate relationship between anthropology and entertainment magic, revealing how the two fields are more interconnected than initially perceived. The author demonstrates that the endeavors in these two domains matured concurrently, sharing similar stances towards modernity and rationality that mutually influenced each other. As stage magic established its own realm of suspension of disbelief, colonial ethnographers resorted to labeling native ritual performers as charlatans, deceiving gullible individuals into believing their sleight of hand was divine. By examining the interactions between French magicians and North African ritual performers, Jones showcases how the concept of magic became deeply entrenched in anthropological practice.

However, Jones goes beyond merely critiquing the concept of magic. He argues that anthropologists should not discard it altogether but rather engage in a more critical and nuanced examination of its colonial origins. Through this radical reassessment of classic anthropological ideas, "Magic's Reason" offers a fresh perspective on the potential benefits and risks of conducting cross-cultural comparisons.

Jones explores the ways in which the colonial encounter shaped the understanding and representation of magic. He highlights the power dynamics at play, where European colonizers positioned themselves as superior and rational, while indigenous cultures were often portrayed as primitive and irrational. This binary opposition created a framework that marginalized indigenous practices and beliefs, perpetuating the notion that magic was merely a superstition or illusion.

Nevertheless, Jones argues that magic remains a valuable lens through which to understand human behavior and cultural practices. He points out that magic has been used throughout history to convey messages, heal, and manipulate reality, and that it continues to play a significant role in many societies today. By recognizing the complexities and nuances of magic, anthropologists can gain a deeper understanding of the cultural and social contexts in which it operates.

Furthermore, "Magic's Reason" challenges the notion that cross-cultural comparisons are always straightforward or beneficial. The author acknowledges the potential pitfalls and biases that can arise when comparing different cultures, such as the risk of essentializing or flattening complex phenomena. He encourages anthropologists to approach cross-cultural comparisons with a critical eye, recognizing the limitations of their own cultural perspectives and the importance of engaging with local communities in a respectful and collaborative manner.

In conclusion, "Magic's Reason" is a thought-provoking and illuminating book that sheds light on the complex relationship between anthropology and entertainment magic. Through his meticulous research and insightful analysis, Graham M. Jones provides a fresh perspective on the promise and peril of cross-cultural comparisons. By challenging traditional assumptions and engaging in a critical reassessment of classic anthropological ideas, he offers a valuable contribution to the field of anthropology and beyond.

\n Weight: 352g\n
Dimension: 228 x 152 x 14 (mm)\n
ISBN-13: 9780226518688\n \n