Reconstructing the Variant Generation Process of Hadith: Based on the Quantitative and the Isnad-Cum-Matn Analysis

This monograph analyzes hadiths to reconstruct the process of variant generation, focusing on the isnad-cum-matn analysis. Despite many successful studies, accurately presenting the general pattern of variant generation is challenging. The study aims to reconstruct the process by analyzing isnads from various quantitative perspectives and using the isnad-cum-matn analysis.

Format: Hardback
Length: 302 pages
Publication date: 15 April 2023
Publisher: Equinox Publishing Ltd

This monograph is a comprehensive exploration into the analysis of hadiths, with a primary focus on reconstructing the process of variant generation. While medieval authors may have devoted limited attention to the study of textual variations, contemporary researchers have shown a growing interest in this field. These scholars concur that numerous hadiths have undergone reformulation since their initial circulation, and their goal is to trace the trajectory of these reformulations with respect to individual hadiths.

Methodologically, the isnad-cum-matn analysis proposed by Harald Motzki and Gregor Schoeler has proven to be the most successful approach. This method involves examining the transmission process of a hadith through the analysis of isnads, which are the chains of transmission, and then comparing it to the textual development of the hadith, which is analyzed through the examination of its matn (text). Additionally, biographical sources can be consulted to provide further insights.

Despite the effectiveness of this method, achieving precise reconstructions of the variant generation process remains a challenge. This study, consisting of four chapters, aims to address this gap by employing a multifaceted approach. In addition to utilizing the isnad-cum-matn analysis, it explores various quantitative perspectives to gain a deeper understanding of the isnads and their variations.

In the first chapter, the study provides an overview of the historical development of the isnad-cum-matn analysis and its significance in the study of hadiths. It highlights the contributions of early scholars and their methods for analyzing and reconstructing variant generation.

Chapter 2 delves into the theoretical foundations of the isnad-cum-matn analysis and explores its methodological principles. It discusses the concept of correlation, the criteria for evaluating the reliability of isnads, and the role of matn in the textual development of hadiths.

Chapter 3 presents a comprehensive analysis of the isnads from a quantitative perspective. It explores various metrics and statistical techniques to measure the reliability and consistency of the transmission process. The study examines the patterns and trends.

Chapter 4 summarizes the findings and implications of the study. It discusses the challenges and limitations of the current approaches to variant generation analysis and proposes future directions.

In conclusion, this monograph offers a valuable contribution to the field of hadith studies. By employing a quantitative approach and exploring various perspectives, it provides a comprehensive reconstruction of the process of variant generation. The study highlights the significance of the isnad-cum-matn analysis in understanding the historical development of hadiths and sheds light on the challenges and opportunities for future research.

Weight: 730g
Dimension: 163 x 241 x 30 (mm)
ISBN-13: 9781800502178