That Jealous Demon, My Wretched Health: Disease, Death and Composers

The author of this book, a Fellow of the Royal College of Surgeons, explores the disturbed physical and mental health of 70 great composers and attempts to determine the cause of death based on the legal paradigm of a balance of probabilities. He challenges misconceptions such as madness fueling creativity and relates the nature of composition to composers' suffering, showcasing much triumph in adversity.

Format: Hardback
Length: 526 pages
Publication date: 15 June 2018
Publisher: Boydell & Brewer Ltd

Despite facing significant challenges and adversity, the notion that illness fuels composition is a misconception. The health and, particularly, the deaths of composers have sparked controversy and intrigue. Questions such as whether Mozart was poisoned, whether Tchaikovsky committed suicide, and how Beethoven lost his hearing have captivated the public. Unfortunately, much valuable previous scholarship has been tainted by unsubstantiated views, and many composers' reputations have been unfairly tarnished by scandalous commentary, often involving alcoholism or syphilis. This book, written by a Fellow of the Royal College of Surgeons, aims to chart the disturbed physical and mental health of 70 renowned composers. It employs a forensic approach to unravel the evidence and determine the cause of death based on the legal paradigm of a balance of probabilities. The author delves into the circumstances surrounding each composer's final illness or death and assesses how many of them might have fared better with modern treatment. The book is organized thematically, by illness, and challenges numerous misconceptions, such as the notion that madness fuels creativity. It sheds light on the triumphs of composers in adversity and plays a crucial role in rehabilitating their reputations.

Jonathan Noble, the author, is a retired surgeon with a wealth of experience in researching the illnesses and deaths of composers. He holds prestigious fellowships, including those from the Royal College of Surgeons and the British Association of Knee Surgeons. Noble has also served as the President of the British Orthopaedic Sports Trauma Association. Throughout his career, he has provided medical care to athletes, including Test cricketers, Manchester United players, and dancers and musicians in the North of England.

In his book, Noble meticulously examines the lives and deaths of 70 renowned composers, providing a comprehensive account of their physical and mental health challenges. He employs a forensic approach to analyze the available evidence and draw conclusions about the causes of death. The book challenges various misconceptions and stereotypes associated with composers, such as the notion that they are inherently unstable or prone to mental illness. Instead, Noble presents a nuanced and empathetic portrayal of these artists, highlighting their triumphs in adversity and their contributions to the world of music.

One of the book's key strengths is its organization. The chapters are arranged thematically, by illness, allowing readers to gain a deeper understanding of the specific challenges composers faced throughout their lives. This approach not only facilitates a clearer understanding of the composers' health issues but also highlights the resilience and creativity they displayed in the face of adversity.

Throughout the book, Noble challenges numerous misconceptions and stereotypes associated with composers. For instance, he debunks the myth that madness fuels creativity, presenting evidence to the contrary. He also challenges the notion that composers are inherently unstable or prone to alcoholism or other substance abuse. Instead, he suggests that these issues may have been exacerbated by the pressures and demands of the music industry and the societal expectations placed upon composers.

One of the book's most interesting chapters explores the impact of composers' physical health on their creative output. Noble argues that composers often suffered from a range of physical ailments, including chronic pain, respiratory problems, and neurological disorders. These conditions not only affected their ability to perform but also had a profound impact on their composition. He provides examples of composers who struggled with physical health issues but continued to produce exceptional music, highlighting the resilience and determination of these artists.

Another important aspect of the book is its rehabilitation of composers' reputations. Noble argues that many composers have been unfairly tarnished by scandalous commentary and unsubstantiated views. He presents evidence to support the claims of composers who have been accused of misconduct or mental illness, challenging the stereotypes and assumptions that have been perpetuated for centuries. By presenting a balanced and nuanced account of these composers' lives and deaths, Noble aims to restore their rightful place in the annals of music history.

In conclusion, "Suffering for Music: The Disturbed Health and Deaths of 70 Great Composers" is a groundbreaking work that sheds light on the physical and mental health challenges faced by composers throughout history. Written by a Fellow of the Royal College of Surgeons with extensive experience in the field, the book employs a forensic approach to analyze the evidence and determine the causes of death. It challenges numerous misconceptions and stereotypes associated with composers, highlighting their resilience and creativity in the face of adversity. The book also plays a crucial role in rehabilitating the reputations of composers who have been unfairly tarnished by scandalous commentary and unsubstantiated views. By presenting a balanced and nuanced account of these composers' lives and deaths, "Suffering for Music" contributes to a deeper understanding of the human condition and the profound impact of music on our lives.

Weight: 1062g
Dimension: 240 x 163 x 48 (mm)
ISBN-13: 9781783272587