Examining Doctoral Work: Exploring Principles, Criteria and Processes

Examining Doctoral Work examines how the doctoral examination process can be improved to ensure fair, thorough, and productive assessment. It covers key points such as the different forms doctoral submission can take, how examiners are chosen, where to begin when reading a thesis, managing your time as an examiner, what makes a 'good doctoral thesis, how to prepare for the viva, how to develop a preliminary report, the role of the supervisor before, during, and after the viva, examiners' roles and responsibilities, and working through agreements and disagreements.

Format: Paperback / softback
Length: 106 pages
Publication date: 04 September 2020
Publisher: Taylor & Francis Ltd

Examining Doctoral Work delves into the enhancement of doctoral examination practices to maximize the benefits for both examiners and students. Written in a clear and straightforward manner, the book aims to promote fair, thorough, and productive assessment processes. It conducts a comprehensive analysis of both exemplary and suboptimal practices, fostering a culture of fairness and excellence in the evaluation of doctoral theses.

The book begins by exploring the various formats in which doctoral submissions can take place, shedding light on the diverse approaches taken by candidates. It then delves into the selection process of examiners, emphasizing the importance of selecting individuals who are qualified, experienced, and impartial. The next chapter provides valuable guidance on how to approach the task of reading a thesis, offering practical tips and strategies to ensure a thorough and effective evaluation.

Time management is a crucial aspect of the examiner's role, and the book offers practical tips on how to allocate and utilize time effectively during the examination process. It also discusses the criteria for evaluating a doctoral thesis, highlighting the key elements that contribute to a high-quality and impactful work.

Preparing for the viva, a critical component of the doctoral examination, is extensively covered in the book. It provides insights into how to prepare effectively, including strategies for dealing with anxiety, structuring the viva, and responding to questions effectively. The role of the supervisor before, during, and after the viva is also examined, emphasizing the importance of effective communication and support.

Examiners' roles and responsibilities are extensively discussed, including their duties in evaluating the thesis, providing feedback, and resolving any disagreements or agreements that may arise. Working through agreements and disagreements is a key skill for examiners, and the book offers practical strategies for achieving constructive outcomes.

Oral and written feedback is an essential aspect of the examination process, and the book provides guidance on how to deliver feedback effectively. It emphasizes the importance of being clear, concise, and constructive, while also fostering a positive and supportive environment for candidates.

Drawing from a combination of personal experience, existing research, and anecdotal evidence, Examining Doctoral Work offers a comprehensive and practical guide for anyone new to the world of doctoral examination. It is also valuable for experienced examiners who seek to improve their practice and enhance the quality of their evaluations.

In conclusion, Examining Doctoral Work is a valuable resource for anyone involved in the doctoral examination process. By promoting fair, thorough, and productive assessment practices, the book contributes to the advancement of academic excellence and the development of skilled researchers.

Weight: 160g
Dimension: 139 x 216 x 14 (mm)
ISBN-13: 9780367431600