Is Morality Real?: A Debate

Spencer Case and Matt Lutz debate whether objective moral facts exist, exploring topics like the nature of common sense, the meaning of moral language, and why the realism/anti-realism debate matters. Case contends that there are moral truths that don't depend on human beliefs or attitudes, while Lutz maintains that there are no moral truths.

Format: Hardback
Length: 240 pages
Publication date: 07 September 2023
Publisher: Taylor & Francis Ltd

In this captivating book, Spencer Case and Matt Lutz engage in a lively debate on the existence of objective moral facts. The authors delve into the complexities of the moral landscape, exploring the notion that actions such as murder and institutions like slavery are inherently wrong. They also examine the contentious issue of abortion, where opinions often diverge. However, the central question remains: what makes statements about morality true? Should we adopt a realist perspective, believing that moral truths exist independently of human beliefs or attitudes? Or should we embrace anti-realism, suggesting that there are no moral truths to be discovered?

After providing a comprehensive overview of the major contemporary positions in the moral realism debate, the authors present their own preferred views. Case argues that there are moral truths that transcend human beliefs and attitudes, offering a robust defense of moral realism. Lutz, on the other hand, maintains that there are no moral truths, even if they existed, rendering our knowledge of them impossible. Throughout their engaging discussion, the authors explore various topics, including the nature of common sense, the meaning of moral language, and the significance of the realism/anti-realism debate in moral philosophy.

They develop their own arguments and responses, assuming no prior knowledge of metaethics. The result is a highly accessible exchange that provides new students with an opinionated gateway to this important area of moral philosophy. However, seasoned philosophers will also find much to ponder and engage with in this original and thought-provoking work.

Key Features:
Comprehensive Overview: The book offers a comprehensive overview of all the main positions on moral realism, providing a clear and accessible introduction to the topic.

Both Traditional and Original Arguments: The authors present both traditional and original arguments for each position, fostering a nuanced understanding of the debate.

Highly Accessible Language: The language is accessible to students with no prior knowledge of metaethics, while still maintaining intellectual rigor.

Draws upon Recent Literature: The book builds upon recent literature on the realism/anti-realism debate, ensuring that readers are up-to-date with the latest developments in the field.

Limited Technical Terms: The book uses only a limited number of technical terms, which are defined in the glossary for easy reference.

In conclusion, this book is a must-read for anyone interested in moral philosophy, ethics, or the nature of truth. It offers a comprehensive and engaging exploration of the realism/anti-realism debate, providing new students with an opinionated gateway to this important area of study. At the same time, seasoned philosophers will find much to ponder and engage with in this original and thought-provoking work.

Weight: 640g
Dimension: 216 x 138 (mm)
ISBN-13: 9781032023885