The Rational Mind

Scott Sturgeon's The Rational Mind presents an original account of mental states and their dynamics, bridging a deep four-way divide in literature on epistemic rationality. It develops a detailed story of coarse- and fine-grained mental states, offers a novel perspective on their fit together, proposes an engaging theory of rational transitions, and advocates for the use of formal methods to advance our understanding.

Format: Paperback / softback
Length: 384 pages
Publication date: 29 February 2024
Publisher: Oxford University Press

Scott Sturgeon presents an original account of mental states and their dynamics, delving into a comprehensive narrative that encompasses both coarse- and fine-grained mental states. He offers a novel perspective on how these states coalesce, an engaging theory of rational transitions between them, and a fresh viewpoint on how formal methods can enhance our understanding in this domain. By bridging a profound divide in literature on epistemic rationality, Sturgeon's work addresses a deep-seated schism within the field. Formal epistemology, often characterized by its specialized language and resemblance to mathematics, can be alienating to philosophers who are drawn to more traditional explorations of thought experiments in epistemic rationality. Conversely, informal epistemology, with its emphasis on Platonic ideals and its deviation from mathematical formalism, tends to deter philosophers who are attracted to formal models of phenomena. Similarly, the epistemology of coarse-grained states reduces everything to a discussion of rational belief, making the area appear more akin to the foundations of knowledge than practical tools for rational decision-making, such as decision-making under uncertainty.

The Rational Mind, however, stands as a groundbreaking achievement that unifies work in all of these areas for the first time. By integrating insights from formal epistemology, informal epistemology, and the study of coarse-grained mental states, Sturgeon provides a comprehensive framework that sheds light on the complexities of human cognition. Through his innovative approach, he offers a fresh perspective on the rationality of belief, decision-making, and knowledge acquisition, challenging traditional assumptions and paving the way for new insights into the nature of human thought and behavior.

In conclusion, Scott Sturgeon's The Rational Mind is a seminal work that revolutionizes our understanding of mental states and their dynamics. By bridging the divide between formal and informal epistemology, and by integrating insights from coarse-grained mental states, Sturgeon offers a comprehensive and innovative framework that sheds light on the complexities of human cognition. Through his engaging theory of rational transitions and his fresh view of how formal methods can advance our understanding, he provides a valuable contribution to the field of epistemology and has the potential to transform our understanding of human thought and behavior.

Weight: 586g
Dimension: 154 x 236 x 29 (mm)
ISBN-13: 9780198912255